Arbitration clauses are commonly found in franchise agreements. Companies that have to deal with numerous franchisees are especially focused on minimizing the time and expense associated with disputes. However, it is important to remember that arbitration is an alternative to litigation, not an excuse to avoid resolving a conflict. Failing to cooperate with the dispute resolution process can trigger problems, even in a case where the franchise relationship fell apart relatively quickly.
G Six Consulting, LLC entered into a franchise agreement with Dickey’s Barbecue Restaurants to open a location in Illinois. After approximately three months, G Six closed the outlet, and sought relief from Dickey’s in arbitration, alleging that the franchisor did not accurately represent the amount of operating costs. In order to prove its claim, G Six requested testimony from top Dickey’s executives, but the company refused to produce personnel with knowledge of the business relationship.
Given this failure to abide by the rules for the proceeding, the arbitrator awarded G Six more than $700,000, plus interest. Dickey’s then brought the case to federal court, looking to overturn the arbitrator’s decision. This effort was not successful, however. The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas upheld the arbitrator’s award, rejecting Dickey’s assertion that the sanction was unjustified or the result of arbitrator misconduct.
In an arbitration stemming from a franchise dispute, both parties must agree to reasonable discovery terms set forth by the arbitrator. Under the Federal Arbitration Act, decisions of an arbitrator are generally treated with great deference unless it is clear that the decision-maker acted in bad faith or clearly exceeded their powers. Here, the arbitrator acted within their authority to manage discovery and draw adverse inferences or impose sanctions against a recalcitrant party.
While the sharing of information during an arbitration is almost always less onerous than it would be in litigation, parties must still produce relevant witnesses and documents. If a party is obstructing, seek a written directive from the arbitrator requiring them to cooperate.
The Law Offices of Donald W. Hudspeth P.C. in Phoenix handles a wide range of franchise disputes for Arizona clients. Please call 866-696-2033 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.