With so much advertising shifted to online platforms such as Google and Amazon, many companies place an intense focus on finding the right keyword strategy. By paying for specific keywords, advertisers can attract potential customers who enter those terms on the sites while looking for a business that meets their needs. As online marketing has gotten more sophisticated, some companies have paid to have their website show up in a search result when someone enters a name or product associated with a competing business. This might seem like an unfair practice, but does it actually constitute a violation of intellectual property rights?
A case in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit centered on two companies that made devices designed to charge a vehicle’s battery without inflicting damage that can result from overcharging. Deltona Transformer Company trademarked the name “battery tender” and used it to market these products to the public. The NOCO Company started to make similar products and referred to them as battery tenders as well. Subsequently, Deltona successfully sued NOCO for trademark infringement.
Though NOCO ceased referring to its chargers as battery tenders, they did contract with Amazon to have their product appear when someone searched for a battery tender on that site. Deltona sued again, alleging that this also violated their trademark rights. However, the Eleventh Circuit drew on precedent to hold that on its own, using a competitor’s trademark in keyword bidding does not rise to the level of unlawful infringement.
At its core, trademark protection exists so that consumers are not confused about who is putting a particular product or service on the market. A person who searches for “battery tender” on Amazon and then clicks the link to NOCO’s page has no reason to believe that the product is made by Deltona. The keyword bidding mechanism remains strictly behind the scenes.
Despite the decisions in Deltona and other cases, businesses considering bidding for keywords using a competitor’s trademarked name should be careful. Anything in the ad itself that blurs the lines regarding the product’s manufacturer, or utilizes the trademark itself, could qualify as infringement.
The Law Offices of Donald W. Hudspeth P.C. in Phoenix advises Arizona clients on various trademark matters, including disputes over alleged infringement. To make an appointment, please call 866-696-2033 or contact us online.